Is it reasonable to expect it to stop a bear … The 10mm penetrated about 2-inches deeper into the gelatin (14.8″ vs. 12.5″). Alaska Guides carrying 10mm for Bear Defence Sidearm? Can a 10mm kill a Grizzly bear? To stop a big, fast-moving, aggressive bear with a big-bore handgun, one first has to hit that big bear—and hit it well. With trembling hands, you dig out your Garmin inReach Mini and hit the SOS button, not knowing whether your buddy is alive or dead. almost always light Noslers (135gr in 10mm, 115gr in .357 Sig) from Underwood Ammo (or the same weight projectiles in Sierra from Double Tap Ammo). 1992-94 Vintage Interarms Star Megastar 10mm Pistol w/ Box, Manuals, Etc. Non-expanding and with lots of penetration. In fact, 10mm auto rounds serve as a good multi-purpose round. Somehow your handgun is gone, and amidst all the shaking and tearing and roaring, you hope that your buddy is alive enough to activate his inReach Mini. The revolver leaps to the sky from recoil but drops smoothly back on target and booms again. Before you say it, yes. That, and I wanted a lot of power in the cartridge. The 10mm Auto devotees point out that the 10mm has more energy remaining at 100 yards than the .45 ACP does at the muzzle. A massive bear with frosted fur is lying across the wriggling body of your hunting partner, and you hear the chilling scrape of Ursus arctos horribilis canines on human skull. If you’re an auto frame person, go with a Glock 10mm. I will be carrying a load throwing a 140-gr. It seems a lot of people are leaning this direction, as hard hitting bear loads are now available, and the idea of 15-16 rounds seems appealing. We pick the best guns and ammo from our giant Gear Issue. All Rights Reserved. grizzly it took nine rounds to put the bear down, and by all accounts it seems like the shots were pretty well-placed. Next, there’s the power factor. Situations in which a handgun must be used to stop a bear happen very fast and are extremely stressful and adrenaline fueled. If you body-shoot an attacking bear front-on, those 10mm bullets must be chosen for extremely deep, straight-line penetration to compromise as many vital organs as possible, and they must shrug off any bone—no matter how massive and dense—encountered along the way. I’ve always been comfortable shooting at 50 yards with the 3.8” XD-M in 9mm. Then I read an article on a brown bear being shot and killed in self defense (was charging) with a … But a 10mm AR pistol makes an awful lot of sense in some specific circumstances. Hard cast, gas-checked (except 10mm Auto) heavy-for-caliber lead bullets precisely matched with temperature stable powders and primers, all housed in highest quality brass cases. But there is an important caveat: Expanding bullets are out. From its excellent sights to its 15-round capacity to its good ergonomics, the 10mm XD-M is a great choice for predator defense. This round has gained popularity in recent years and I highly recommend giving it a try! However, the 10mm Auto is no slouch: it will absolutely do the trick if you place your shots properly. 10mm vs .357 Magnum for Bear Protection in Alaska 44 Magnum Desert Eagle L6 Ballistics Test with Underwood XP and 180gr JHP Review 9mm vs. 40 S&W vs. 357 Sig vs. 45 Auto vs 10mm Liberty Ammunition Short Barrel Ballistics Gel Test Revolver fans haven’t been left out: S&W has had the 10mm … Freel’s remarks are sobering, but they’re also useful. With good shot placement and hard-cast or solid-copper bullets, a 10mm bullet can take down a bear. 10mm generally packs higher muzzle energies thanks in large part to the larger bullets. Purists suggest that adequate versions begin with the .44 Magnum—and it qualifies only out of polite respect for Dirty Harry. It’s better, the thinking goes, to put two or three—or six or eight—well-placed smaller bullets into a bear than one or two poorly placed big bullets. By Massad Ayoob Photos: Joseph R. Novelozo I put the sights dead on the blue steel gong 100 yards away, held the rough-gripped pistol snug on the sandbags and pressed the trigger. Roundnose designs are also notorious for deflecting off bone. Is it a good choice for this role, though? That's why HSM's exclusive Bear Load has been a most popular seller since its introduction in 2011. Fighting the urge to run, you dump the rest of your magazine into the bear’s head and shoulders as it slumps to the ground. They expand to fast and I doubt will get to a Bears heart/lungs. I will be carrying a load throwing a 140-gr. On various forums and articles (mainly by people who don't live up here) there is been lots of talk about how the 10mm is used by Guides in Alaska. Both of the pistols we have issued under the Gun Talk name have been 10s, but I’m not taking either of them. Here are the impressive new 6.5 PRC rifles from SHOT Show 2020 in Las Vegas, Nevada! So I have decided on a Glock 20 (10mm) for defense on an Alaskan trip in the future. It’s also worth noting that the man who had to fire nine times to get out alive immediately went and bought a 10mm afterward. Hitching your suspenders, you grab your sidearm from the nearby stump and bunny hop frantically toward camp as very human-like screams erupt. Really, my idea of a suitable bear caliber starts at .338 Winchester Magnum and goes up from there, but you can wear a 10mm pistol all day long when hunting or in camp, and you can’t do the same with a rifle in .338 Win. Grilled Venison Loin with Caper-Mustard Sauce Recipe, New for 2021: Nosler M48 Mountain Carbon Rifle New Chamberings, Stock Updates, Best Whitetail Shot Placement with a Rifle. (double lung) the beat ran about 20 yds and died. Hundreds of encounters with Polar Bears have been concluded with this handgun, chambered for 10MM Auto, and all these encounters have been reported in Patrol Dispatches over a period of several years. The edges of the flat nose should be crisp to enable them to sever arteries and tendons instead of pushing them aside as they pass, like a roundnose bullet. U.S.A. –-(Ammoland.com)-On 19 September 2018, Jimmy Cox used his Glock model 20 10mm to stop the charging grizzly bear pictured, at 10 feet. They are tenacious and are accustomed to fighting. Your big-bore revolver pounds a heavy bullet into the oncoming bear. Live The Armory Life. More trim. If you hunt with a handgun, or you need a powerful pistol for protection in bear country, then 10mm loaded to full power actually is an attractive option. And I can quit anytime I want. From its excellent sights to its 15-round capacity to its good ergonomics, the 10mm XD-M is a great choice for predator defense. The 10mm is NOT comparable to .41M, I don't care what anyone says (10mm gets about 1/2 way to 265 gr. On one occasion a 10mm handgun was used, and the poor man defending himself from a charging grizzly fell backward while trying to back off. When Springfield Armory brought out the XD-M in 10mm, I immediately bought the 4.5″ model. Two experts square off. In our testing, the 10mm and 44 magnum rounds performed somewhat similarly. The latest content straight to your inbox plus an automatic entry to each of our monthly gun giveaways! Doug Burris Jr's typical mule deer taken in 1969, could just be one record that will never be broken. Educators talk about the law of primacy. Study after study, both in the ballistics lab and based on real world shootout data, show the .45 is not statistically better than any other common self-defense round (9mm, .40 S&W, 10mm, .357 Magnum, etc.). There are documented cases of 10mm killing black, brown, and Grizzly bears. Underwood you have will about as effective as any 10mm for defensive shooting black bear. It’s early morning and you’re just finishing your morning constitutional behind the designated tree when a commotion and some unfriendly bear-like noises erupt from camp. Frantically, you pull it out of the sky and slam the trigger again, then one more time as the bear takes you to the earth. 10mm is plenty for black bear. All rights reserved. I don’t want to hear about my choice of gun /caliber. The bear flinches and snaps at its shoulder, folding its chin into its own rich fur, blossoming now with blood and erupting crimson foam with every bone-grinding growl. Some people consider it almost sacrilegious to recommend a semi-automatic handgun chambered in 10mm Auto as a bear-defense gun. As George pointed out, there is a WORLD of difference between a blackie and a griz But here's a question, IF you are going to buy a new gun, why not get a Ruger Redhawk in 44 magnum or 45 Long Colt. If one is to use the Glock 10mm for bear defense then FMJ 200 grain or Buffalo Bore 220 grain loads folks. Well, a 10mm, but that’s not surprising. If you use the right ammo type, 10mm will absolutely stop bears, even Grizzlies. |   certified instructor prior to handling any firearm and be sure to read your owner’s manual. Trouble is, few hunters can accurately and efficiently handle one of these big-bore sixguns. Next, there’s the power factor. Unless we face a situation similar to this, we’ll never actually know which type of shooter we are, although we can—and should—train to be collected, accurate, and fast under pressure. Well, almost faster. Uptain’s 10mm Glock semi-automatic pistol was with a pack and shirt a short distance away, and Chubon’s bear spray was in a pack, the state agencies said. Nose profiles should be flat and broad. Avoid them. The Springfield feels better in my hands. Honestly, I have small hands, and I just can’t handle that big grip very well. I just don’t want to! © 2021 Springfield Armory. 10mm seemed to be the best common auto pistol round for bear protection. The heavy revolvers are more difficult and expensive to shoot, and very few people ever get comfortable with them.”. These pistols hold two or three times the shots of a big-bore revolver, and most hunters find them relatively easy to shoot accurately and quickly. These The Glock 20 has several big advantages that make it a great bear-defense gun. With good shot placement and hard-cast or solid-copper bullets, a 10mm bullet can take down a bear. There are documented cases of 10mm killing black, brown, and Grizzly bears. One leader will be caring a Glock in 10mm. Even with similar bullets, however, it appears the 10mm does slightly better. Now I’m shopping for and buying holsters. Remember that bears are much different creatures than hooved, flight-response deer. For ultimate reliability, you want a revolver, right? Is the .308 the Perfect North American Big Game Cartridge? From trajectory to penetration to recoil, we evaluate this cartridge for the big-game use case. Full-power loads are not a good self-defense option in most cases given their excessive penetration. This is a niche market, but there are 10mm AR pistols out there for you and they include…. Btw, a brown bear is larger than black bear and considered more dangerous, which again demonstrates the amount of luck, and a steady hand this man had in defending his life with a handgun and his perfect placement of those head shots. deep penetrating bullet at 1,500 fps. The polymer autoloader weighs a bit less than my stainless-steel revolver, but once I load the Springfield with 16 rounds, the difference will disappear. The bang was instantly followed by a ting. @ 1430 FPS). That means the things you learn first stick hard. The Range Officer Elite 10mm offers a great deal of power and accuracy in a reasonably priced package. I usually end up with three holsters for each carry pistol. That’s 700 ft.-lbs. You have time to realize that screaming was a mistake as your gun begins to buck in your palm. The 10mm is a newcomer in the hunting world, but has become a big player in the market for bear hunters or anyone needing extra power. The stand out 10mm loads are from Cor-Bon and they are probably superior to anything you can handload. Does anyone know of Alaska Guides who carrys a 10mm for Bear defence? Petersen's Hunting Staff - January 28, 2021. JHPs are made for HUMANS!!! 10mm vs .357 Magnum for Bear Protection in Alaska 44 Magnum Desert Eagle L6 Ballistics Test with Underwood XP and 180gr JHP Review 9mm vs. 40 S&W vs. 357 Sig vs. 45 Auto vs 10mm Liberty Ammunition Short Barrel Ballistics Gel Test The 180 gr. I’ve carried XD-M pistols from time to time. Fans of the .45 ACP counter that the .45 is bigger at 100 yards than the 10mm is at the muzzle. To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine. Dan Wesson’s Longslide Bruin Is An Autoloading Equalizer For The Great Outdoors. All Petersen's Hunting subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. As a teen I spent summers with my siblings at my dad’s in Alaska, and there’d be reports of bear maulings quite often. Use these steps to accurately estimate a bruin's size. Hit hard twice, the bear convulses, hunching like a bodybuilder doing a sit-up, and ends in the fetal position. The 10mm, loaded hot with hard cast FMJ, is fully capable of penetrating the skull of a brown bear. Craig Boddington breaks down where hunters should aim on a whitetail that provides the best possible margin for error. I will be carrying a load throwing a 140-gr. A new line of over-and-under shotguns that won't break the bank. In the end, only you can decide what backup gun to carry for bears. If you use the right ammo type, 10mm will absolutely stop bears, even Grizzlies. One leader will be caring a Glock in 10mm. Hello everyone! Okay Iv got a question. deep penetrating bullet at 1,500 fps. I don't know which one. Author, outdoorsman, gun rights activist, and firearms enthusiast for more than five decades, Tom Gresham hosts Tom Gresham's Gun Talk, the first nationally-syndicated radio show about guns and the shooting sports, and is also the producer and co-host of the Guns & Gear, GunVenture, and First Person Defender television series. Plus, with a couple of years of experience carrying an XD-M on my belt, it seemed an easy choice. Is a Cellular Trail Camera Right for You? That’s 700 ft.-lbs. So there! Frantically, you slam 10mm bullets at the oncoming bear in rapid fire. Yes, I know that Glock has had a 10mm full-size pistol for years. A fairly recent trend has seen increasing numbers of hunters packing semiautomatic 10mm Auto sidearms in bear country. What's better for a bear back up gun: a magnum revolver or a 10mm auto? But, I have always in the past carried a revolver when in “bear country.” Why? Puffs of dust around it signal you’re missing a few, but with frightened elation, you know some are connecting, too. I carry a semi-auto pistol every day to protect myself from two-legged predators. Live The Armory Life. That’s about the same as I get from the .357 Magnum loads I’ve been carrying in the mountains, and I’ll have 15+1 of them in the gun. I know we get ridiculous bear threads all the time but I have a real question. I know we get ridiculous bear threads all the time but I have a real question. What are your thoughts on the 10mm for grizzly defense? A sound that is half prehistoric battle roar, half paralyzed shriek of terror involuntarily erupts from your throat as you raise your handgun. Non-expanding and with lots of penetration. Each caliber's specially developed load has been expertly crafted from only the best of components. Dust puffs past him and you know you missed a shot, but most of your shots are connecting. That’s why it’s difficult to change your views, and it’s hard to overcome bad training, but in this case, I’m fighting what “everyone knows” about revolvers being more reliable than semi-autos. Not enough to slow the bear, but as it looms close, so big it’s impossible to miss, you’re pointing and pulling fast. Hundreds of encounters with Polar Bears have been concluded with this handgun, chambered for 10MM Auto, and all these encounters have been reported in Patrol Dispatches over a period of several years. Forget any handgun.”. I don't know what ammo was used but it was a one shot kill at about 25 yds. The local scouts are going on a 50 mile hike this summer through north Utah there are medium sized black bears in the area. I like the way they shoot. @ 1430 FPS). Started by carrying a .44 mag 629. Faster than thought, the bear whips around, fishhooks into the wind and charges. The 10mm is frequently chosen over the .357 for its stopping power, and over the .45ACP because it’s slightly easier to handle. What we can decide is what sort of sidearm we’ll pack in bear country. First, what am I taking with me? Tyler Freel, an Alaskan who has taken four grizzlies with a recurve bow, offered this sage advice. With the inReach Mini activated, you move to assist your shredded hunting partner. Huffing spine-melting roars, it sinks to the ground as you sledgehammer it with every bullet remaining in the cylinder of your revolver. Hunters seeking big game stick to bullets in the area of 150 to 220 grains, with 180 grains on average. If you can handle a big-bore revolver with heavy loads, they do offer profoundly more on-impact authority over any other handgun. Events go to slow motion as the bear knocks you down with its chest, crushing the air from your lungs. Without talking about the numbers, both calibers are very impressive for power.